The experiment ended up not only proving that humans are quick to behave and act how they are told they should behave and act but also the aggressive nature dormant in most people.
The guards had no training in how to handle their jobs, but caught on. However over the years multiple experiments that have been carried out have been ethically wrong and have resulted in the contenders of the experiments left mentally and physically damaged, and some even resulting in death, like dying the Nazis experiments when patients suffered all kinds of horrific mutilations Cohen, Their psychological state was also analysed.
For those of you who are particularly interested in the SPE the video below is a BBC documentary about the study which includes talking to Zimbardo and the participants from the study. Lessons from the Stanford Prison Experiment. Ethics Leave a Reply Your email address will not be published.
In return they were given no instructions of what they shall expect. The experiment turned into a complicated game to the young men and they started to lose sight of reality. What are the interpersonal dynamics in a simulated prison? I likely would have only terminated it based on my own personal comfort level with witnessing emotional stress and physical humiliation.
Zimbardo realized the significance of the experiment. However, aggressive and violent behavior quickly appeared on the behalf of the group playing the role of the guards, while prisoners became depressed and passive.
As Zimbardo admitted, he also became immersed with his role of his role of being the instructor, providing orders to the guards. As for today, analyzing the connection of ethics and the Stanford Prison Experiment the participants were treated unethical for the people right from the beginning.
Based on the extreme effects the experiment had on its participants, it would likely be the best choice to not conduct a follow-up study and make volunteers relive their experiences. However, based on the knowledge we have thanks to some of the results of this experiment, it is difficult to say that these experiments should never have been done; rather, it is a learning experience for the researcher and for future researchers, who now have tools as well as checks and balances in place that can help them conduct studies that have integrity as well as strong ethics.
It could be suggested that participants were not fully protected from harm, but as this distress was only temporary do the ends justify the means? Issues can arise when deception is used.
It is logical that Shaugnessy is describing the failure of several ethical issues and criticizes the experiment as a whole.
For forty years it was criticized as well as argued when it came to the relation of ethics and psychology. On the other hand, guards did no realize that they could leave their role either. The physical harm was never proven on record however many critics do predict that mental effects of the experience should have generated automatic physical reactions.Ethics and Stanford Prison Experiment Essay Words | 9 Pages Ethics and the Stanford Prison Experiment In Philipp Zimbardo carried out one of the most ethically controversial psychological experiment the ‘Stanford Prison Experiment’.
Ethics in psychological research and testing is one of the most important issues today. The Stanford Prison Experiment, conducted over 40 years ago, brought these ethical issues into the limelight and remains one of the most controversial studies in the history of studying human behavior.
Essay on Stanford Prison Experiment Essay on Stanford Prison Experiment InPhilip K. Zimbardo, a psychology professor at Stanford University began researching how prisoners and guards internalize submissive and authoritarian roles.
Ethics and Stanford Prison Experiment Essay Ethics and the Stanford Prison Experiment In Philipp Zimbardo carried out one of the most ethically controversial psychological experiment the ‘ Stanford Prison Experiment ’. Following this experiment however, in was the Stanford prison experiment, which took breaching of the ethical guidelines a step too far (Shuttleworth, ).
The Stanford Prison experiment took place from the fourteenth to the twentieth of Augustand consisted of 24 regular volunteers who were each either allocated the role of a. Running head: Stanford Prison Experiment The Ethics of Zimbardos Stanford Prison Experiment The Milgram experiment on obedience to authority figures may seem quite unethical, due to the fact it reveals unwelcome truths about human nature, although consensus shows that most participants and the general public agree that it is ethical.Download