Source B differs from other extracts that are typical of the time. So unknowingly he could be seen as not caring for his men, but rather trying to appease the nation.
Undoubtly there will be casualties in war and it is the job of the governing bodies to appease the people of the nation, since in war you need the people of the nation to be on your side, hence resulting in what Haig says in source B. One views him as a cold hearted man trying to kill innocent men by putting them into war and another shows him trying to win the war for Britain.
So in conclusion the answer is that source A can only be used as evidence against him but not to prove that he did not care about the lives of his men. In this instance it can be simply seen as Haig being realistic and keeping all his options open.
Simply by looking at it superficially, one can come to the inference that Haig did not care much about the lives of his men. Firstly, if it was addressed to the public whereby his men would be aware of his thoughts and concerns, it could be depicted that he did not care about his men.
As a result of this source A is a primary source as it was written at the time. However, one can only know this because of other more typical sources of the time. However you could also look at it from the aspect that Haig was actually being realistic about the position they were in because it is true that in a war there will always be casualties.
We now know that 60, men died or were injured in the first few hours. One must understand that both sources have their limitations. Hence, this shows us that Haig was only interested in promoting himself to the public and would really say anything about his men, which would better himself.
This can be seen as a fatalistic attitude as it could reduce Haig to not really making an effort to secure the position of his men and thus endangering the lives of his men. We can assume from this knowledge that since Haig was addressing the public he was telling them what he thought they wanted to hear.
The probability is that there will be losses of men and the nation will have to live with it. Looking at it directly and at what is simply written in this source we would assume straight away he did not care about his men since he did not believe that they could be victorious without serious life loss.
There are two ways of interpreting this source based on whom it was for. The source is all about the death toll that Britain would be expecting.
Secondly if it was just for the attention of the Commander himself and a few other elite members other Generals it would not come to be known by the army officers themselves.Free Essay: Haig's Reputation as the Butcher of the Somme In the run up to the war, Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig was appointed the Director of Military.
Essay Writing Guide. Learn the art of brilliant essay writing with help from our teachers. Learn more. AS and A Level.
Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero? Douglas Haig has been blamed for the slaughter of thousands of men who were under his control in World War One.
The Battle of the Somme was one of his worst fights were 55 British soldiers. Free Essay: General Haig's Background and Military Experience General Haig is one of the most important men in world war history, made famous for his tactics Home Flashcards Flashcards Home Create Flashcards Defining Field Marshal General Sir Douglas Haig Essay.
Source A is an extract from a diary entry written by Sir Earl Douglas Haig (Commander of the Battle of the Somme) in July As a result of this source A is a primary source as it was written at the time. The Sir douglas haig is one of the most popular assignments among students' documents.
If you are stuck with writing or missing ideas, scroll down and find inspiration in the best samples. Sir douglas haig is quite a rare and popular topic for writing an essay, but it certainly is in our database.
General Sir Douglas Haig, British Commander-in-Chief on the western front, was not really ready to attack in mid He wanted to wait until later in the year and attack in Flanders (not the Somme). We will write a custom essay sample on Haig Butcher of the Somme specifically for you for only $ $/page.